Elizabeth Montgomery is best known for her iconic role as Samantha in the classic TV series Bewitched, but her talent went far beyond twitching her nose on the small screen. Throughout her career, she delivered powerful performances in a range of TV movies and dramas that showcased her acting range, especially in emotionally intense and socially conscious roles.
Here are five of Elizabeth Montgomery’s best movies that prove she was one of Hollywood’s most underrated stars:
1. A Case of Rape (1974)
In this gripping made-for-TV drama, Montgomery plays Ellen Harrod, a young wife who is brutally assaulted and then faces a harrowing legal battle to get justice. Her performance is raw and heart-wrenching, shining a light on the flaws in the justice system. This role earned her an Emmy nomination and remains one of her most acclaimed performances.
2. The Legend of Lizzie Borden (1975)
Montgomery shocked audiences with her portrayal of the infamous Lizzie Borden, accused of murdering her father and stepmother with an axe. Stepping far away from her Bewitched persona, she delivered a chilling and ambiguous performance that kept viewers guessing until the end. The film is a cult classic and earned her another Emmy nod.
3. Dark Victory (1976)
A remake of the 1939 Bette Davis film, this television version saw Montgomery take on the role of a glamorous woman diagnosed with a terminal illness. She portrayed the emotional journey with sensitivity and strength, further proving her dramatic chops.
4. Amos (1985)
In this powerful TV drama, Montgomery co-stars with Kirk Douglas. She plays a cold-hearted nursing home administrator in a film that tackles elder abuse and institutional neglect. Her icy, commanding presence added depth to the story, and critics praised her ability to bring intensity to even unsympathetic roles.
5. Black Widow Murders: The Blanche Taylor Moore Story (1993)
In one of her last and most haunting roles, Montgomery plays real-life convicted murderer Blanche Taylor Moore. The chilling performance was based on a true story, and she captured the character’s charm and sinister nature perfectly. It was a fitting final role before her passing in 1995.
